District Court grants final approval to forgive $6 billion in student loans

Courts Student Lending Department of Education Settlement

On November 15, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California granted final approval to a class action settlement to forgive certain federal student loan borrower debt. According to the motion for preliminary approval, the plaintiffs are federal student loan borrowers who filed borrower defense (BD) applications with the Department of Education, requesting that the Department discharge their federal student loans because of misconduct committed by their schools. They brought the case to challenge the Department’s delay in making decisions on BD applications. The motion noted that the plaintiffs alleged, “the Department’s inaction was due to a deliberate and uniform policy abandoning BD decision making, a choice that caused a mounting backlog.” In a supplemental complaint filed after discovery, plaintiffs further alleged that the Department “adopted an unlawful policy that presumptively denied BD applications regardless of their merit, and then, pursuant to this policy, sent tens of thousands of legally insufficient denial notices (the ‘Form Denial Notices’) to borrowers, including some of the Named Plaintiffs.” The class consists of approximately 264,000 people who have a BD application pending as of June 22, 2022. The “automatic relief group” consists of applicants who attended one of more than 150 colleges for which the Department found common evidence of institutional misconduct. The motion also noted “it has determined that every class member whose relevant loan debt is associated with those schools should be provided presumptive relief under the settlement due to strong indicia regarding substantial misconduct by the listed schools, whether credibly alleged or in some instances proven, and the high rate of class members with applications related to the listed schools.” Under the terms of the settlement, $6 billion in loans will be canceled for the borrowers.