District Court preliminarily approves $2.25 million settlement resolving credit card upgrade claims

Courts Class Action Consumer Finance Credit Cards Settlement

On August 29, the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey preliminarily approved a class action settlement in which a national bank agreed to pay $2.25 million to resolve misleading credit card upgrade claims made to secured credit card holders. Plaintiffs alleged in their motion for preliminary approval that they each signed an agreement with the bank that said if they used and maintained a secured credit card account for seven consecutive billing months without defaulting they would be eligible to automatically “graduate” to an unsecured credit card. Transitioning to an unsecured credit card allows customers to regain control of the collateral deposits and receive a prorated refund of the annual fee they paid while they had secured cards, plaintiffs asserted. Plaintiffs claimed that while the bank’s “form contract and promotional materials promised a meaningful review of secured card accounts after seven months in good standing that review, in fact, did not occur in a fashion consistent with the parties’ contract.” The bank denied the claims. According to court documents, this past January the bank amended the graduation provision at issue in its agreement for secured credit cards to “more adequately disclose how a cardholder becomes eligible for an unsecured credit card.” The court deemed the proposed settlement to be “fair, adequate and reasonable to the settlement class,” and granted class certification. If granted final approval, class members would be awarded a portion of the annual fee paid on their secured credit card.