Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive Acts or Practices
Practice Overview
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the Federal Trade Commission, state attorneys general, and prudential bank regulators continue to be aggressive in their approaches to monitoring unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices under federal and state consumer protection laws.
Buckley has extensive experience defending against unfair, deceptive, and abusive claims on behalf of the financial services industry. Our experience includes defending against enforcement actions and lawsuits brought by the CFPB and prudential bank regulators, FTC investigations and lawsuits, state attorneys general matters, and class action litigation. We represent clients on a wide range of matters, including fair and responsible lending and servicing, sales and marketing practices, overdraft protection, deposit reconciliation, payment processing, credit reporting, debt collection, and privacy and data security issues.
Our lawyers advise clients on all consumer financial products and services, including mortgage origination and servicing, short-term consumer loans, automobile and other installment loans, credit, debit and stored value cards, student loan origination and servicing, and retail banking products. We are well-versed in a full array of ancillary products like payday lending and tax refund advances.
Buckley also assists clients on UDAAP matters outside the enforcement context by helping financial services companies develop compliance programs and policies, conduct risk assessments, evaluate marketing, develop new products, review disclosures, perform mock CFPB examinations, prepare legal analyses of potential violations, and provide training to boards of directors, senior management, and other key personnel.
Representative work in this area includes:
- Represented Flagstar Bank in the first CFPB enforcement action of its mortgage servicing rules that was based, in part, on allegations of unfair acts and practices and resulted in an administrative consent order settlement for $37.5 million relating to default servicing loss-mitigation practices
- Represented Verizon Wireless in a multistate, multiagency investigation and settlement alleging that it permitted “cramming” by allowing third parties to place unauthorized charges on consumers’ wireless phone bills
- Represented a credit card issuer in the second CFPB enforcement action, issued jointly with the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, in which the agencies alleged deceptive marketing and sales practices related to add-on products
- Performed regulatory and transactional due diligences of lenders to advise potential investors and purchasers on the lenders’ compliance with federal and state UDAAP prohibitions
- Represented First National Bank of Omaha in a CFPB enforcement action alleging UDAAP violations relating to credit card add-on products
- Represented Customers Bank in an enforcement action before the Federal Reserve Board (FRB) concerning UDAAP allegations related to financial aid disbursement services for students offered in conjunction with a third party
- Represented bank clients in responding to FDIC inquiries related to UDAAP risk posed by marketplace lender/bank partnership arrangements
- Represented a credit reporting bureau in a CFPB enforcement action alleging UDAAP violations relating to the marketing of credit scores to consumers
- Represented a regional bank in the first CFPB enforcement action that cited both UDAAP and Regulation DD violations in connection with the bank’s marketing of a free checking product
- Defended financial institutions in class actions alleging violations of state unfair and deceptive practices laws
Articles
"CFPB revises UDAAP manual to include discriminatory practices" by Sasha Leonhardt, Jeffrey P. Naimon, and John R. Coleman (The Banking Law Journal)
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (“CFPB”) has announced significant revisions to its Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive Acts or Practices (“UDAAP”) exam manual, in particular highlighting the CFPB’s view that its broad authority under UDAAP allows it to address discriminatory conduct in the...
ArticlesSpecial Alert: DOJ settles claims of algorithmic bias
On June 21, the United States Department of Justice announced that it had secured a “groundbreaking” settlement resolving claims brought against a large social media platform for allegedly engaging in discriminatory advertising in violation of the Fair Housing Act. The settlement is one of the...
Special Alerts"TCPA relief for Covid-19 communications could extend to financial institutions" by Ali M. Abugheida and Geoffrey L. Warner (Bloomberg Law)
Financial institutions face unprecedented and rapidly evolving challenges in the wake of the Covid-19 pandemic, including the need to communicate quickly and efficiently with customers in the face of government-issued stay-at-home orders. But the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, with its steep...
Articles"Alternative data and fair lending face off: The relationship is complicated" by Caroline M. Stapleton (Mortgage Compliance Magazine)
Thinking of getting into a relationship with alternative data? You're not alone. Use of "alternate data," a term broadly used to describe consumer information gathered from non-conventional sources, is becoming increasingly attractive to mortgage lenders, their service providers, and even consumers...
Articles"Neither forgiven nor forgotten: Taxation and UDAAP concerns with collecting charged off debt" by Sasha Leonhardt (Bloomberg BNA)
When debtors are unable to pay their debts, creditors are left with a choice: (i) allow the consumer to pay a lesser amount, if possible, to settle the obligation and recover some funds; or (ii) charge off the debt and cease all collection efforts. Regardless of the path chosen, each has potential...
Articles"The role of State AGs in solving student loan crisis" by Sasha Leonhardt (Law360)
State attorneys general are the chief legal officers of their state; state attorneys general are the chief law enforcement officers of their state; and state attorneys general must protect their citizens and vigorously enforce their state’s consumer protection statutes. As broad as these powers and...
ArticlesMarshall T. Bell and Megan E. Whitehill Authored a Law360 Article, "Ability-To-Repay Enforcement Comes To Auto Finance"
In recent years, regulators and enforcement agencies have eagerly exercised their authority to prosecute what they perceive as unfair or deceptive acts and practices (UDAPs). Unfortunately for the auto finance industry, these regulators and agencies show no sign of tapping the brakes on such...
ArticlesWhat's Driving Regulation of Auto Ancillary Products
Federal and state regulatory scrutiny of the automobile finance industry has accelerated over the last several months. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB or the Bureau) and the Department of Justice (DOJ) recently announced the fourth public resolution with an indirect auto finance...
ArticlesLost in Translation: Financial Services for Consumers with Limited English Proficiency
Susanna Khalil and Jessica Pollet authored "Lost in Translation: Financial Services for Consumers with Limited English Proficiency," which was published May 18, 2015 in the WestLaw Journal Bank & Lender Liability. They discuss the emerging area of access to credit for people with limited...
ArticlesNew Day For RESPA: The UDAAPification Of Section 8
The Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act has gone the "UDAAPified" way of debt collection — this time, through enforcement rather than guidance. In July 2013, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Bulletin 2013-07 announced that the principles underlying the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act...
ArticlesCaveat Emptor or Caveat Vendor? The Evolution of Unfairness in Federal Consumer Protection Law
Under the Federal Trade Commission’s original interpretation of unfair or deceptive acts or practices law, financial institutions could feel some sense of security that, if they provided a consumer with a clear understanding of a proposed transaction, the burden was on the consumer to determine...
ArticlesSpecial Alert: CFPB Takes Enforcement Action Against "Buy-Here, Pay-Here" Auto Dealer for Alleged Unfair Collection and Credit Reporting Tactics
On November 19, the CFPB announced an enforcement action against a ‘buy-here, pay-here’ auto dealer alleging unfair debt collection practices and the furnishing of inaccurate information about customers to credit reporting agencies. ‘Buy-here, pay-here’ auto dealers typically do not assign their...
ArticlesThe CFPB's 'UDAAPification' of Consumer Protection Law
Questions about the scope of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's jurisdiction abound for financial institutions and other entities that work with them. What are the boundaries of the CFPB’s authority? How might these parameters expand in the future? Are there other ways the CFPB may take...
ArticlesSpecial Alert: CFPB Bulletin Re-Emphasizes Focus on Mortgage Servicing Transfers
On August 19, 2014, the CFPB issued Bulletin 2014-01 to address “potential risks to consumers that may arise in connection with transfers of residential mortgage servicing rights.” The bulletin, which is the latest in a series of CFPB regulations, statements, and guidance on this subject, replaces...
ArticlesPom v. Coke Will Impact Financial Services Too
Legal and compliance departments, take note: the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent decision in Pom Wonderful LLC v.Coca-Cola Co. confirms that even if an institution’s conduct meets the specific requirements established by the federal agency responsible for implementing one federal consumer protection...
ArticlesA Broader Application of Fair Debt Collection Principles
On July 10, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau issued new debt collection guidance and announced broad application of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act under Sections 1031 and 1036 of the Dodd-Frank Act. The guidance suggests that the CFPB views the acts and practices made illegal by the...
Articles
News & Blogs
CFPB issues Summer ’23 supervisory highlights
On July 26, the CFPB released its Summer 2023 issue of Supervisory Highlights , which covers enforcement actions in areas such as auto origination, auto servicing, consumer reporting, debt collection, deposits, fair lending, information technology, mortgage origination, mortgage servicing, payday...
InfoBytesNYDFS: Auto loan borrowers are entitled to rebates for cancelled ancillary products
On July 18, NYDFS sent a letter reminding regulated auto lenders and auto loan servicers that they are responsible for ensuring certain rebates are credited to consumers whose vehicles were repossessed or were a total loss. During its examinations, NYDFS identified instances where certain...
InfoBytesCFPB alleges UDAAP violations by “lease-to-own” financer
On July 19, the CFPB announced it is suing a lease-to-own finance company that provides services that allows consumers, typically with limited access to traditional forms of credit for their financing, to finance merchandise or services over a 12-month period. According to the complaint , the...
InfoBytesCFPB, states sue company over deceptive student lending and collection
On July 13, the CFPB joined state attorneys general from Washington, Oregon, Delaware, Minnesota, Illinois, Wisconsin, Massachusetts, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Virginia in taking action against an education firm accused of engaging in deceptive marketing and unfair debt collection...
InfoBytesStates endorse CFPB’s policy statement on abusive conduct
On July 6, the California attorney announced that he had joined a coalition of state attorneys general in submitting a comment letter endorsing the CFPB’s recently issued policy statement on abusive conduct in consumer financial markets. The multi-state coalition comprises Arizona, California,...
InfoBytesCFPB levies $25 million penalty for EFTA violations
On June 27, the CFPB entered a consent order against a Nebraska-based payment processor and its Delaware-based subsidiary for alleged violations of the EFTA (Regulation E), and the Consumer Financial Protection Act’s prohibition against unfair acts and practices. According to the Bureau, in 2021...
InfoBytesDefault judgment entered against provider of immigration bonds
The U.S. District Court for the Western District of Virginia recently entered default judgment against defendants accused of misrepresenting the cost of immigration bond services and deceiving migrants to keep them paying monthly fees by making false threats of deportation for failure to pay. As...
InfoBytesCFPB: Reopening a closed account could be a UDAAP
On May 10, the CFPB released Circular 2023-02 to opine that unilaterally reopening a closed account without a customer’s permission in order to process a transaction is a likely violation of federal law, particularly if a bank collects fees on the account. “When a bank unilaterally chooses to open...
InfoBytesOCC, FDIC say some overdraft fees may be unfair or deceptive
On April 26, the OCC and FDIC issued supervisory guidance addressing consumer compliance risks associated with bank overdraft practices. (See OCC Bulletin 2023-12 and FDIC FIL-19-2023 .) The guidance highlighted certain practices that may result in increased risk exposure, including assessing...
InfoBytesDistrict Court won’t stay CFPB litigation with credit reporter
On April 13, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois denied a credit reporting agency’s (CRA) bid to stay litigation filed by the CFPB alleging deceptive practices related to the marketing and sale of credit scores, credit reports, and credit-monitoring products to consumers...
InfoBytes
Press Releases & Announcements
BuckleySandler Hosts Eighth Annual Fair Lending Today Conference
BuckleySandler LLP hosted its eighth annual Fair Lending Today conference in Washington, DC on March 13-14, 2016. The two-day event featured an evening of interactive roundtable discussions on fair lending issues, followed by a full day of seminars. The sessions were led by BuckleySandler attorneys...
Press ReleasesBuckley Sandler Hosts Annual Fair Lending Today Conference
Buckley Sandler LLP hosted its annual Fair Lending Today conference in Washington, DC, March 15-16, 2015. The two-day event featured an evening of interactive roundtable discussions on fair lending issues, followed by a full day of seminars. The roundtables and seminars were led by Buckley Sandler...
Press Releases
Our Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive Acts or Practices Team
Partners
Counsel
FYI
"TCPA relief for Covid-19 communications could extend to financial institutions" by Ali M. Abugheida and Geoffrey L. Warner (Bloomberg Law)
Recent Blog Posts
-
July 28, 2023
CFPB issues Summer ’23 supervisory highlights
-
July 21, 2023
NYDFS: Auto loan borrowers are entitled to rebates for cancelled ancillary products
-
July 21, 2023
CFPB alleges UDAAP violations by “lease-to-own” financer
-
July 14, 2023
CFPB, states sue company over deceptive student lending and collection
-
July 14, 2023
States endorse CFPB’s policy statement on abusive conduct