Skip to main content
Menu Icon
Close

InfoBytes Blog

Financial Services Law Insights and Observations

Filter

Subscribe to our InfoBytes Blog weekly newsletter and other publications for news affecting the financial services industry.

  • Department of Energy discontinues crypto mining survey following a settlement agreement

    Fintech

    On March 1, a cryptocurrency company (plaintiff) and the U.S. Department of Energy submitted a settlement agreement to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas to discontinue an emergency crypto mining survey once approved by the Office of Management and Budget.

    According to the settlement agreement, the Department of Energy initiated an emergency three-year collection of a Cryptocurrency Mining Facilities Survey in January, which the plaintiff claimed did not comply with various statutory and regulatory requirements for the emergency collection of information. Following the court’s approval of the plaintiff’s temporary restraining order, which protected plaintiffs from completing the survey issued by the Department of Energy and protected any information they may have already submitted, the Department of Energy discontinued its emergency collection, and said it will proceed through notice-and-comment procedures for approval of any collection of information covering such data. As a result of the discontinuation of the emergency collection request, no entity or person is required to respond to the survey.

    As part of the settlement agreement, the Department of Energy will destroy any information it had already received from survey responses. In addition to a $2,199.45 payment for the plaintiffs’ litigation expenses, the Department of Energy also agreed to publish a new Federal Register notice of a proposed collection of information and withdraw its original notice. 

    Fintech Department of Energy Cryptocurrency Digital Assets Settlement Courts Bitcoin

  • U.S. Attorney General taps professor to lead new technology-focused roles

    Fintech

    On February 22, the U.S. Attorney General, Merrick B. Garland, announced that he tapped Jonathan Mayer to head the DOJ’s first Chief Science and Technology Advisory and Chief Artificial Intelligence (AI) Officer roles. The roles are housed in the DOJ’s Office of Legal Policy which is developing a team of technical and policy experts in technology-related areas important to the Department’s responsibilities. These topics include cybersecurity and AI with the aim to advise leadership and collaborate with other components across the Department and with federal partners on cutting-edge technological issues. As the first Chief Science and Technology Advisor, Mayer will contribute technical expertise on cybersecurity, AI, and emergent technology matters.

    The Chief AI Officer role was created pursuant to a presidential executive order on the Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy Development and Use of Artificial Intelligence. In this role, Mayer will work on intra-departmental and cross-agency efforts on AI and adjacent issues, and he will also lead the Justice Department’s newly established Emerging Technology Board, which coordinates and governs AI and other emerging technologies across the Department.

    Mayer has a PhD in computer science from Stanford University and a J.D. from Stanford Law School. Mayer is an assistant professor at Princeton University’s Department of Computer Science and School of Public and International Affairs where his research is focused on the intersection of technology, policy, and law with an emphasis in criminal procedure, national security, and consumer protection.

    Fintech Department of Justice Artificial Intelligence

  • Financial Stability Board’s letter addresses financial topics for upcoming G20 meeting

    Fintech

    On February 20, the Financial Stability Board (FSB) released a letter from its Chair, Klaas Knot, to the G20 Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors ahead of the February 28-29 G20 meeting, setting up the agenda for maintaining global financial stability. The FSB is an organization made up of senior financial officials from G20 countries as well as international financial organizations including the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, and the European Central Bank. The letter addressed financial system vulnerabilities, including the takeaways from the March 2023 banking crisis, nonbank financial intermediation (NBFI), digitalization of finance, climate change effects, and cross-border payment efficiency.

    On the first topic, the letter highlighted lessons wrought by the March 2023 banking crisis; the FSB advocated the need for public-sector backstop funding mechanisms, and more analytical work on interest rate and liquidity risk to explore vulnerabilities. On NBFI, the letter noted a structural vulnerability in asset management as the “potential mismatch between the liquidity of fund investments and daily redemption of fund units in open-ended funds[.]” On digital innovation, the letter urges the G20 to closely monitor any risks to financial stability, including crypto, tokens, and artificial intelligence. On climate change, the FSB plans to further analyze climate-related financial risks to financial stability. Last, on cross-border payments, the G20 Cross-border Payments Roadmap goal is to make cross-border payments “faster, cheaper, and more transparent and inclusive” while keeping their integrity and maintaining the “safety of the system.” The letter noted that FSB has collaborated with AML experts in both the public and private sectors to “increase the efficiency of payments systems and further enhance their integrity and safety.”

     

    Fintech Financial Stability Board G20 Of Interest to Non-US Persons Cross Border Activities Climate-Related Financial Risks

  • FDIC orders bank to plan termination of relationships with “significant” fintech partners

    Recently, the FDIC released a consent order against a Tennessee bank as part of its release of January Enforcement Decisions and Orders. The FDIC stated that within sixty days of the effective date of the consent order, the bank must “submit a general contingency plan to the Regional Director… [on] how the [b]ank will administer an effective and orderly termination with significant third-party FinTech partners,” as part of its Third-Party Risk Management program for the bank. The Program must assess and manage the risks posed by all fintech firms associated with the bank. It will include policies related to due diligence and risk assessment criteria that are appropriate to the products and services provided by the fintech partner. The bank must also engage an independent firm for completion of a comprehensive Banking-as-a-Service Risk Assessment Report.

    The bank further consented, without admitting or denying any charges of unsafe or unsound banking practices, to board supervision of the bank’s management and approval of the bank’s policies and objectives, qualified management, the Regional Director’s prior consent for new or expanded lines of business that would result in an annual 10 percent growth in total assets or liabilities, and a comprehensive strategic plan.

     

    Bank Regulatory FDIC Consent Order Fintech Risk Management Enforcement

  • NY Fed highlights an increase in unsecured loans from fintech firms in report, primarily among subprime lenders

    Fintech

    On November 21, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York released a report on the rise and then contraction of unsecured personal loans from 2019 to 2023 for nonbank or fintech companies, and the role of alternative data and underwriting in that growth.

    The report looked at how the economic conditions from 2019 to 2022 “created an ideal environment for FinTech firms to increase their loan originations.” It specifically noted that the U.S. government-issued stimulus payments and student loan repayment moratorium enabled fintech companies to expand their services to low- and moderate-income borrowers, including those with subprime credit. The report also looked at fintech’s role in that growth, what consumer segments are utilizing unsecured personal loans, the overall growth of the products, and the subsequent tightening of credit. Finally, the NY Fed discussed various fintech models and analyzed which models service the needs of low- and moderate-income households. 

     

    Fintech Federal Reserve Federal Reserve Bank of New York Subprime Consumer Finance New York

  • Fed’s Vice Chair remarks on payments innovation, CBDCs, and financial inclusion

    On October 27, Fed Vice Chair for Supervision, Michael Barr, delivered a speech at the Economics of Payments XII Conference discussing the Fed’s place in the payments system and highlighting its role as a bank supervisor and operator of key payment infrastructure. Emphasizing the Fed’s introduction of its FedNow instant payment service (covered by InfoBytes here), which was designed to enable secure instant payments in response to the increasing demand for secure and convenient payment options, Barr encouraged banks to build upon the new payment infrastructure. He also noted that ongoing experimentation with new payment technologies, such as stablecoins, creates a need for regulation, particularly where an asset is “pegged to government-issued currencies.” 

    Regarding central bank digital currencies (CBDCs), the Fed is engaged in research and in discussions with various stakeholders; however, it has not decided on whether to issue a CBDC. The Vice Chair stressed that any move in this direction would require “clear support” from the Executive Branch and authorization from Congress.

    Barr emphasized the Fed’s commitment to working with the international community to improve cross-border payment systems as well as the need for research into both traditional and emerging payment methods, noting that innovation should “promote broad access and financial inclusion.”  Finally, the remarks touched on the Fed’s proposed revisions to the interchange fee cap for debit card issuers, with a call for public input on the matter (covered by InfoBytes here).

    Bank Regulatory Fintech Federal Reserve Payments CBDC Financial Inclusion Stablecoins

  • CFPB announces civil money penalty against nonbank, alleges EFTA and CFPA violations

    Federal Issues

    On October 17, the CFPB announced an enforcement action against a nonbank international money transfer provider for alleged deceptive practices and illegal consumer waivers. According to the consent order, the company facilitated remittance transfers through its app that required consumers to sign a “remittance services agreement,” which included a clause protecting the company from liability for negligence over $1,000. The Bureau alleged that such waiver violated the Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA) and its implementing Regulation E, including Subpart B, known as the Remittance Transfer Rule, by (i) requiring consumers sign an improper limited liability clause to waive their rights; (ii) failing to provide contact and cancellation information in disclosures, and other required terms; (iii) failing to provide a timely receipt when payment is made for a transfer; (iv) failing to develop and maintain required policies and procedures for error resolution; (v) failing to investigate and determine whether an error occurred, possibly preventing consumers from receiving refunds or other remedies they were entitled to; and (vi) failing to accurately disclose exchange rates and the date of fund availability. The CFPB further alleged that the company’s representations regarding the speed (“instantly” or “within seconds”) and cost (“with no fees”) of its remittance transfers to consumers were inaccurate and constituted violations of CFPA. The order requires the company to pay a $1.5 million civil money penalty and provide an additional $1.5 in consumer redress. The company must also take measures to ensure future compliance.

    Federal Issues Fintech CFPB CFPA EFTA Nonbank Unfair Enforcement Consumer Protection

  • Fed governor speaks on responsible innovation in money and payments

    On October 17, Federal Reserve Board Governor Michelle Bowman provided remarks on innovation in money and payments, including crypto assets, central bank digital currency (CBDC), and the development of instant payments, in which she laid out her vision for “responsible innovation,” which recognizes the important role of private-sector innovation and leverages the U.S. banking system supported by clear prudential supervision and regulation. With respect to CBDC, Bowman said that she has yet to see a compelling argument that CBDC could address frictions within the payment system, promote financial inclusion, or provide the public with access to safe central bank money any more effectively or efficiently than alternatives. She explained that, given that the U.S. has a safe and well-functioning banking system, the potential uses of a U.S. CBDC remain unclear and, at the same time, could introduce significant risks and tradeoffs. Bowman also expressed skepticism over stablecoins, stating that in practice they have been less secure, less stable, and less regulated than traditional forms of money. Finally, Bowman discussed technological innovations in wholesale payments, which are large-value, interbank transactions. Bowman said that the Fed is researching emerging technologies that could enable or be supported by future Fed-operated payment infrastructures, including depository institutions transacting with “tokenized” forms of digital central bank money. Bowman noted that banks and other eligible institutions already hold central bank money as digital balances at the Fed. She also stressed that wholesale payment infrastructures operated by the Fed “underpin domestic and international financial activities” by serving as a “foundation” for payments and the broader financial system. Because these wholesale systems function “safely and efficiently” today, it is necessary to investigate and understand the potential opportunities, risks, and tradeoffs for wholesale payment innovation to support a safe and efficient U.S. payment system.

    Find continuing InfoBytes coverage on CBDCs here.

    Bank Regulatory Federal Issues Federal Reserve Cryptocurrency CBDC Fintech Digital Assets Money Service / Money Transmitters

  • Chopra foreshadows expanding oversight over digital payments

    Fintech

    On October 6, CFPB Director Rohit Chopra spoke at a digital payments event where he described the risks posed by private digital currencies and digital payments systems and provided steps that would increase the CFPB oversight so as to help protect consumers from these risks.

    Chopra stated that from a consumer regulator’s perspective, it is important to safeguard against the risks of private currencies issued by nonbanks, which include the potential for sudden devaluation of the digital currency, intrusive data surveillance, censorship, private regulations that favor the issuer’s commercial interests, challenges with error resolution, and consumer fraud.

    Further, Chopra shared what he believes are warranted steps to ensure that private digital dollars and payments systems do not harm consumers:

    • The CFPB will issue supplemental orders to certain large technology platforms to acquire more data and information to better ascertain their business practices, especially with respect to the use of sensitive personal data and any issuance of private currencies.
    • To reduce the harms of errors, hacks, and unauthorized transfers, the Bureau will explore providing additional guidance on the applicability of the Electronic Fund Transfer Act with respect to private digital dollars and other virtual currencies for consumer and retail use.
    • The CFPB will use appropriate authorities to conduct supervisory examinations of nonbanks operating consumer payment platforms, including the authority over service providers to large depository institutions and the authority over large participants, which would subject nonbanks meeting a particular size threshold to CFPB supervision.
    • The Bureau will publish a proposed rule regarding personal financial data rights pursuant to Section 1033 of the Consumer Financial Protection Act, which will seek to accelerate America’s shift to open, competitive, and decentralized banking, while also seeking to safeguard against misuse of personal financial data.

    Additionally, Chopra stated the Financial Stability Oversight Council should consider exercising its authority under Title VIII of the Dodd-Frank Act to designate activity as, or as likely to become, a systemically important payment, clearing, or settlement activity so as to provide other agencies with critical oversight and tools to ensure that a stablecoin is actually stable.

    Fintech Federal Issues CFPB Supervision Consumer Protection Digital Assets

  • NYDFS updates criteria for virtual currency regulation

    State Issues

    Adrienne Harris, Superintendent of the New York State Department of Financial Services (“DFS”) issued an update on the VOLT initiative, an ongoing project to enhance DFS’s role as a virtual currency regulator. Superintendent Harris published proposed guidance adopting enhanced criteria for procedures to list and de-list virtual currencies as well as updated guidance for designating virtual currencies to the DFS “Greenlist.”

    The new General Framework for Greenlisted Coins sets (i) heightened risk assessment standards for coin-listing policies and enhances requirements for consumer-facing products; and (ii) new requirements associated with coin-delisting policies. Under the new guidance, a virtual currency entity that seeks to self-certify coins must create a coin-listing policy and may not self-certify any coins until such possibly has a written approval from DFS. A coin-listing policy must contain and be based on a robust governance structure; comprehensive risk assessment; consideration of factors to identify and mitigate risks involved in each coin and its uses; and policies and procedures to conduct continued monitoring of the coin to ensure consistent safety and soundness compliance.

    The new framework does not require prior approval from the DFS to list coins included on the Greenlist, but does require virtual currency entities that choose to list such coins to (i) provide advance notification to DFS and (ii) have a DFS-approved coin-delisting policy.

    State Issues Fintech NYDFS Digital Assets Cryptocurrency Risk Management

Pages

Upcoming Events