District Court grants motion to dismiss in privacy suit

Courts Privacy Cyber Risk & Data Security California Class Action

On February 17, the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware granted a motion to dismiss a putative class action suit for lack of Article III standing, in which plaintiffs alleged that the defendant violated their privacy rights by intercepting and recording mouse clicks and other website visit information. According to the memorandum opinion, the plaintiffs alleged defendant’s recording of that information violated, among other things, the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) and the Federal Wiretap Act. In finding the plaintiffs’ failed to plead a concrete injury, the district court found while the “[p]laintiffs have a legally cognizable interest in controlling their personal information and that intrusion upon that interest would amount to a concrete injury[,]” they failed to identify how any of their personal information was implicated in the complaint. The court explained: “[p]laintiffs fail to explain how either [the defendants] possession of anonymized, non-personal data regarding their browsing activities on [the defendant’s] website harms their privacy interests in any way.” The district court also noted that the plaintiffs did not make any allegations to suggest a risk of imminent or substantial future harm.